Election 2026 · Public beta

Independent, source-first accountability

TheStatedRecordFind a race
Back to the race record

Issue record

Taxes and the SALT cap

In short

Cait Conley's campaign would end the cap on the state and local tax (SALT) deduction. Mike Lawler's campaign points to the 2025 tax law he voted for, which raised the SALT cap to $40,000 and added tip and overtime deductions. On the record, that cap drops back to $10,000 in 2030, and the tip and overtime deductions end after 2028. The record does not settle his figures on local tax savings.

Campaign positions

What each campaign says.

Cait Conley

Would end the cap on the state and local tax deduction entirely, and pass the PRO Act and other pro-worker laws.

Mike Lawler

Points to the 2025 tax law he voted for: a SALT cap raised to $40,000, a $2,200 child tax credit, and new deductions for seniors, tips and overtime. Has introduced bills for tax credits on school supplies and youth sports equipment.

Evidence timeline

What the record shows.

  1. campaign position

    Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

    The SALT cap rises temporarily, with income/filing limits, then returns to $10,000 in 2030. His $4,000 savings, 90% share, earlier $40,000 promise and largest-ever claim remain unverified.

    Read the full check

    Full detail

    Lawler said the 2025 law delivered the largest tax cut in American history, put more than $4,000 back in Hudson Valley families’ pockets and fulfilled his promise to raise the SALT cap from $10,000 to $40,000. He also said over 90% of Hudson Valley taxpayers could fully deduct their state and local taxes. Lawler voted Yea on the May 22, 2025 House bill and Aye on final House concurrence July 3. Public Law 119-21 sets the SALT itemized-deduction cap at $40,000 for 2025 and $40,400 for 2026, with 1% annual increases through 2029 and a return to $10,000 in 2030. Married-separate limits are half. The cap is reduced by 30% of modified adjusted gross income above $500,000 in 2025 or $505,000 in 2026, subject to the statutory floor. His January 2025 op-ed had advocated $100,000 for single filers and $200,000 jointly. JCT’s July 1 score of Senate-passed tax provisions estimated about $4.475 trillion less revenue over 2025-2034 relative to present law. His campaign calculator gives $3,293 for a typical family of four and repeats a 90% residents estimate. Why there is no verdict: The enacted cap change is documented, but the precise earlier $40,000 promise, largest-ever historical comparison, more-than-$4,000 local household amount and over-90% full-deduction share remain unverified. Each requires a defined population, dates and baseline. The January proposal was larger; its enactment is not claimed here. Itemization, income phaseout and actual taxes paid determine eligibility. Lower examples with different assumptions do not automatically disprove the debate amount, and the revenue score is not a cash payment to each family. Limit: The enacted cap change is documented, but the precise earlier $40,000 promise, largest-ever historical comparison, more-than-$4,000 local household amount and over-90% full-deduction share remain unverified. Each requires a defined population, dates and baseline. The January proposal was larger; its enactment is not claimed here. Itemization, income phaseout and actual taxes paid determine eligibility. Lower examples with different assumptions do not automatically disprove the debate amount, and the revenue score is not a cash payment to each family. Debate wording is paraphrased from native captions.

  2. campaign position

    Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

    The 2025-2028 law deducts qualified tips up to $25,000 and the overtime premium, with caps and income limits. It does not end every tax on tips or all overtime pay.

    Read the full check

    Full detail

    Lawler described the tax package as providing no tax on tips and no tax on overtime. Sections 70201 and 70202 create federal income-tax deductions for qualified tips and qualified overtime for 2025-2028, available to itemizers and non-itemizers. Tips are capped at $25,000 per return; overtime at $12,500, or $25,000 jointly. Each deduction is reduced by $100 for each $1,000 of modified adjusted gross income above $150,000, or $300,000 jointly. Qualified overtime is the FLSA-required premium above regular pay, generally the extra half in time-and-a-half. Tips must meet occupation, voluntary-payment, reporting and other statutory conditions. Married taxpayers must file jointly and qualifying Social Security numbers are required. Why there is no verdict: These are conditional, temporary federal deductions. The literal no-tax wording does not establish elimination of every tax on every tip or all pay earned during overtime hours. Payroll taxes, state treatment and each taxpayer’s final liability are separate questions. Limit: These are conditional, temporary federal deductions. The literal no-tax wording does not establish elimination of every tax on every tip or all pay earned during overtime hours. Payroll taxes, state treatment and each taxpayer’s final liability are separate questions. Debate wording is paraphrased from native captions.

See something wrong or incomplete? Report it for review.

Sources16 source records

How we use sources

  1. Policyhttps://caitconley.com/policy/

    Cait for New York · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Twelve policy sections. Undated; read October 1, 2026.

    candidate statement

    For: Cait Conley: campaign position

  2. Issueshttps://www.lawlerforcongress.com/issues/

    Lawler for Congress, Inc. · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Fifteen issue sections, most of them lists of bills and votes he names. Undated; read October 1, 2026.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: campaign position; Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  3. News 12 NY17 debate: lawler tax cut superlative 4000 (4:37)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIU9kcsAldc&t=277s

    News 12 · Published Sep 28, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    September 28, 2026 debate. Statement paraphrased from retained native captions. One transcript is available, so no verbatim quotation is certified; neighboring opponent assertions are excluded.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  4. News 12 NY17 debate: lawler salt quadrupled (4:47)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIU9kcsAldc&t=287s

    News 12 · Published Sep 28, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    September 28, 2026 debate. Statement paraphrased from retained native captions. One transcript is available, so no verbatim quotation is certified; neighboring opponent assertions are excluded.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  5. News 12 NY17 debate: lawler salt 90 percent (4:53)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIU9kcsAldc&t=293s

    News 12 · Published Sep 28, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    September 28, 2026 debate. Statement paraphrased from retained native captions. One transcript is available, so no verbatim quotation is certified; neighboring opponent assertions are excluded.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  6. Meet Mikehttps://www.lawlerforcongress.com/about/

    Lawler for Congress, Inc. · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Campaign biography and a list of what it says he has done in Congress. Undated.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  7. Public Law 119-21, the 2025 reconciliation act (H.R. 1)https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-119publ21/html/PLAW-119publ21.htm

    U.S. Government Publishing Office · Published Jul 4, 2025 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Signed July 4, 2025. Sec. 70120 raises the SALT cap to $40,000 for 2025, rising 1% a year through 2029, phased down above $500,000 of income, and back to $10,000 from 2030. Sec. 70103 adds a $6,000 deduction for each person 65 or older through 2028. Sec. 70104 sets the child credit at $2,200. Secs. 70201 and 70202 add capped deductions for tips and overtime.

    official legislative record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  8. IRS 2025 Form 1040 instructions: SALT and new deductionshttps://www.irs.gov/instructions/i1040gi

    Internal Revenue Service · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    2025 instructions explain itemization, limits, income phaseouts and qualifying conditions. A deduction lowers taxable income; it is not a payment.

    official office record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  9. Lawler’s January 2025 SALT proposalhttps://lawler.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=3633

    Office of Rep. Mike Lawler · Published Jan 13, 2025 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    January 13, 2025 first-person op-ed proposed $100,000/$200,000 caps. This supports prior advocacy, not an exact $40,000 promise.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  10. JCT JCX-35-25: Senate-passed tax provisions, present-law score (document)

    Joint Committee on Taxation · Published Jul 1, 2025 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    July 1, 2025 Senate-text score uses the present-law 2025-2034 baseline, with scheduled expirations. It is not a historical adjusted ranking or a household cash-payment calculation.

    official legislative record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  11. Lawler campaign tax-relief calculator and household assumptionshttps://www.lawlerforcongress.com/taxrelief/

    Mike Lawler campaign · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Lists $3,293 for a typical family of four and 90% of residents. Neither supplies a district-wide liability model for the debate’s $4,000/taxpayer assertions.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  12. H.R. 1 (119th Congress), the 2025 reconciliation acthttps://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/1

    Congress.gov · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Passed the House 215-214 on May 22, 2025 and 218-214 on July 3, 2025. Became Public Law 119-21.

    official legislative record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  13. House Roll Call 145, 2025: H.R. 1, on passagehttps://clerk.house.gov/Votes/2025145

    Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    May 22, 2025. Carried 215-214. Lawler is recorded Yea.

    official legislative record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  14. House Roll Call 190, 2025: H.R. 1, on agreeing to the Senate amendmenthttps://clerk.house.gov/Votes/2025190

    Office of the Clerk, U.S. House of Representatives · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    July 3, 2025. Carried 218-214. Lawler is recorded Aye.

    official legislative record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  15. News 12 NY17 debate: lawler tips overtime (4:56)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIU9kcsAldc&t=296s

    News 12 · Published Sep 28, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    September 28, 2026 debate. Statement paraphrased from retained native captions. One transcript is available, so no verbatim quotation is certified; neighboring opponent assertions are excluded.

    candidate statement

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this

  16. IRS guidance on qualified tips and overtime for 2025https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/treasury-irs-provide-guidance-for-individuals-who-received-tips-or-overtime-during-tax-year-2025

    Internal Revenue Service · Reviewed Oct 7, 2026

    Explains temporary federal income-tax deductions, caps, phaseouts and FLSA premium limits. It does not announce universal payroll or state-tax exemptions.

    official office record

    For: Mike Lawler: record does not settle this